The St. Louis Cardinals have unexpectedly remained in the playoff race, currently tied for the final NL Wild Card spot with the Giants and Padres. Despite outperforming expectations, the team’s direction at the trade deadline remains uncertain, with options to buy, sell, or do a combination of both. One of their biggest decisions involves star closer Ryan Helsley, whose contract expires after the season.
While the front office seems hesitant to move him, analysts argue that the Cardinals should trade Helsley regardless of their place in the standings. His trade value remains high—despite a slight dip from last year’s 49-save season when he won NL Reliever of the Year—and contenders would likely overpay for a proven late-inning weapon. With a lack of healthy, MLB-ready pitchers beyond Michael McGreevy, dealing Helsley could help replenish the farm system.
If they hold onto him, the team risks losing him for just a compensation pick in free agency. Even if St. Louis continues to contend, they’re not viewed as a true championship threat in 2025, making it smarter to focus on building for the future. Trading Helsley now would help new President of Baseball Operations Chaim Bloom reshape the roster without being bogged down by past indecision.
