The Cincinnati Reds’ 2025 campaign has been full of ups and downs, and no player reflects that more clearly than second baseman Matt McLain. Once considered a crucial piece of the Reds’ future, McLain has seen his offensive performance drop off significantly. Now, many fans and analysts are starting to question whether his long-term role may shift to that of a utility player rather than a permanent fixture in the lineup.
At the same time, the pressure is building from below. The fanbase has been vocal about promoting top prospect Sal Stewart, a 21-year-old slugger who’s been tearing up the minor leagues. Stewart’s bat has shown promise at every level, and with the Reds’ offense struggling for consistency, there’s growing hope he could provide a spark. He’s also been working on his defensive versatility — including taking reps at second base — positioning himself as a strong candidate to take over for McLain.
But Stewart isn’t the only name in the mix.
Edwin Arroyo, another rising infield prospect, is quietly re-emerging as a contender for second base duties. Arroyo has long been praised for his defense and overall athleticism, and with his offense steadily improving, he’s becoming harder to overlook. Originally acquired in the 2022 blockbuster trade that sent Luis Castillo to Seattle, Arroyo was part of a package that also included Noelvi Marte. While Marte has drawn more attention, Arroyo has been making quiet but meaningful progress in the minors.
After missing all of 2024 due to shoulder surgery, Arroyo is back in action this year with Double-A Chattanooga. Through 97 games, he’s batting .280/.342/.367 with 38 RBIs — showing a consistent ability to get on base and keep innings alive. While his power numbers aren’t quite back yet, most scouts expect that part of his game to return in time.
What makes Arroyo stand out is his all-around game. As a switch-hitter who focuses on making contact and using the whole field, he’s the kind of player who can disrupt pitchers and keep defenses honest. He also brings speed on the bases and isn’t afraid to take extra bags, whether it’s through steals or aggressive baserunning. Defensively, he’s reliable and versatile — exactly the kind of skill set that could make him an everyday second baseman if McLain’s struggles continue.
Meanwhile, McLain’s numbers paint a concerning picture: he’s slashing just .222/.302/.335 with 11 home runs and 39 RBIs. Despite the Reds’ coaching staff trying to help him break out of his slump — including giving him more rest and lowering him in the batting order — the results haven’t improved much. And with the Reds still in the playoff hunt, patience is starting to run thin.
The Reds have been building a roster filled with exciting young talent, especially homegrown players. For McLain, that means the pressure is on to prove he still belongs. But for players like Stewart and Arroyo, the door is open. Both are in position to claim a starting role, especially if McLain can’t bounce back.
One thing is becoming clearer: Cincinnati has options at second base — and the competition is real.
